The three discs in this set collect all the work by this short lived group, The Jazz Modes. Of particular interest are the two albums under Julius Watkins' name he recorded for the Blue Note label-now available on CD, or used if you can find them. Talking about these two albums, the personnel consists of Watkins-French horn, Hank Mobley-tenor sax, Duke Jordan-piano, the great Oscar Pettiford-bass, and Art Blakey-drums, with Perry Lopez-guitar.
The remaining albums have slightly differing personnel, but the core players are Watkins (who played with Coltrane, Mingus, Miles Davis, Gil Evans, and many others), Charlie Rouse (who played with Monk for years)-tenor sax, and Gildo Mahones-piano. Other players throughout consist of Art Taylor, Kenny Clarke, Paul Chambers, and Sahib Shibab. There's a few others showing up on bass and drums, along with Eileen Gilbert-on mostly wordless soprano vocals, Janet Putnam-harp (on 2 tracks only), and Chino Pozo-congas. This release is closer to 3 1/2 "stars" — the half for experimenting with the soprano voice in a jazz setting. Otherwise this is straight 1950's jazz-before the great changes began to happen in the 1960's.
The 30 page booklet contains an essay on the group as a whole, the primary players, original liner notes, (then) contemporary reviews, and a number of photos and reproductions of the album covers. Also included is song information, dates and who plays on which album. Again, some of this music is perhaps 3 or 3 1/2 "stars". But overall you have to give the principle players much credit for trying something new and different-especially during the relatively button-downed 1950's. A word about the vocals. To present day ears Eileen Gilbert's vocals will come as a bit of a shock. While her voice is a fine soprano, the juxtaposition within a jazz setting is hard to get into. Remember, this was the late 50's, and Rouse and Watkins (especially) were experimenting with a different approach to jazz. Some may like the combination, some will not. But underneath the vocals is some well arranged jazz. So you've been warned.
Don't let the French horn scare you away. This is some fine/very fine straight ahead jazz as they played it in the late 50's. The rhythm section(s) keep everything moving along on the up tempo tunes, and are suitably restrained on the ballads. All three of the principle players get room to solo throughout these albums. Rouse's big sound is right at home on these tunes, and Watkins' horn-sounding like a French horn-is used in much the same manner as any more conventional horn in jazz. Mahone's piano is straight out of the be-bop style of jazz, and fits in very well.
Songs are a combination of standards or (mostly) Watkins' compositions. But no matter which tune, this very fine, unique group plays each song as if it were their own. Straight ahead 1950's jazz/Watkins/Rouse fans need to hear this collection. This was experimental jazz in the 50's-the French horn, the impressionistic vocals, all were an attempt to find something new and different. But even if their music didn't catch on, it's still some good yet different, small group jazz. Period jazz fans may want to check this out-and having all the albums by this group in one collection is very handy, along with a useful booklet. It's definitely of it's era-certainly different than music of the present. A interesting sometimes good side street off the main boulevard of jazz.
*Stuart Jefferson (amazon.com)*
*CD 1*
1 - Dancing On The Ceiling
(Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart)
2 - Legend
(Gildo Mahones)
3 - Temptation
(Arthur Freed, Nacio Herb Brown)
4 - Episode
(Julius Watkins)
5 - Dancing In The Dark
(Arthur Schwartz, Howard Dietz)
6 - Goodbye
(Gordon Jenkins)
7 - Town And Country
(Varon)
8 - When The Blues Comes On
(Alvin G. Cohn, Charles Isaiah Darwin)
9 - Blue Modes
(Julius Watkins)
10 - You Are Too Beautiful
(Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart)
11 - So Far
(Richard Rodgers, Oscar Hammerstein II)
12 - Idle Evening [Jazz Garden Suite, part I]
(Julius Watkins)
13 - Garden Delights [Jazz Garden Suite, part II]
(Julius Watkins)
14 - Strange Tale [Jazz Garden Suite, part III]
(Julius Watkins)
15 - Two Songs [Jazz Garden Suite, part IV]
(Julius Watkins)
16 - Stallion
(Gildo Mahones)
17 - Baubles, Bangles And Beads
(Alexander Borodin, George Forrest, Robert Wright)
18 - Autumn Leaves
(Jacques Prévert, Johnny Mercer, Joseph Kosma)
19 - The Golden Chariot
(Gildo Mahones)
20 - Let's Try
(Charlees Isaiah Darwin, Paulette Girard)
21 - Bohemia
(Ed Smollett, Charles E. Shirley, Mynell Allen)
22 - Cath Her
(Julius Watkins)
*CD 2*
1 - Hoo Tai
(Julius Watkins)
2 - Mood In Scarlet
(Julius Watkins)
3 - Linda Delia
(Julius Watkins, George Butcher)
4 - I've Got You Under My Skin
(Cole Porter)
5 - We Can Talk It Over
(Julius Watkins)
6 - Standing On The Corner
(Frank Loesser)
7 - Joey, Joey, Joey
(Frank Loesser)
8 - Warm All Over
(Frank Loesser)
9 - Happy To Make Your Acquaintance
(Frank Loesser)
10 - My Heart Is So Full Of You
(Frank Loesser)
11 - The Most Happy Fella
(Frank Loesser)
12 - Don't Cry
(Frank Loesser)
13 - Like A Woman
(Frank Loesser)
14 - Somebody Somewhere
(Frank Loesser)
15 - The Oblong
(Julius Watkins)
16 - 1-2-3-4-0 In Syncopation
(Julius Watkins, Princess Orelia Benskina)
17 - Blue Flame
(Julius Watkins)
18 - Mood In Motion
(Julius Watkins)
*CD 3*
1 - Knittin
(Charlie Rouse)
2 - This 'N That
(Charlie Rouse)
3 - Glad That I Found You
(Julius Watkins)
4 - Princess
(Julius Watkins, Princess Orelia Benskina)
5 - Sextette
(Gerry Mulligan)
6 - The Golden Touch
(Quincy Jones)
7 - Cable Car
(Oscar Pettiford, Sonny Clark)
8 - Trictrotism
(Oscar Pettiford)
9 - Edge Of Love
(Charles Ables, Goode, Baker)
10 - Oscar Rides Again
(Oscar Pettiford)
11 - Linda Delia
(Julius Watkins, George Butcher)
12 - Perpetuation
(Julius Watkins)
13 - I Have Known
(Julius Watkins, Gene Morgan)
14 - Leete
(Julius Watkins)
15 - Garden Delights
(Julius Watkins)
16 - Julie Ann
(Julius Watkins, Gene Morgan)
17 - Sparkling Burgundy
(Julius Watkins)
18 - B And D
(Bennie Harris)
19 - Jordu
(Duke Jordan)
*CD 1*
#1 to #6 from the album Jazzville '56, Vol.1 (Dawn DLP1101):
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Paul West (bass), Art Taylor (drums).
Recorded in New York City, June 1956.
[Despite its short duration, this album was a 12" LP, although Side B featured a Gene Quill-Dick Sherman Quintet.]
#7 to #16 from the album Les Jazz Modes (Dawn DLP1108)
[reissued in 1960 as Smart Jazz for the Smart Set (Seeco CELP466).]:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Paul Chambers (bass),
Oscar Pettiford (bass, replaces Chambers on #11, #12 and #14 only),
Janet Putnam (harp on #8 and #10 only), Ron Jefferson (drums),
Eileen Gilbert (soprano vocals on #8, #12 and #14 only).
Recorded in New York City, June 12, 1956.
#17 to #22 from the album Mood in Scarlet (Dawn LP1117):
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Martin Rivera (bass),
Ron Jefferson (drums), Chino Pozo (bongos on #20 and #21).
Reorded in New York City, December 4, 1956.
*CD 2*
#1 to #5 from the album Mood in Scarlet (Dawn LP1117):
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Martin Rivera (bass),
Ron Jefferson (drums), Eileen Gilbert (soprano vocals on #1 and #2).
Recorded in New York City, December 4, 1956.
#6 to #14 from the album The Most Happy Fella (Atlantic LP1280):
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Martin Rivera (bass),
Ron Jefferson (drums), Chino Pozo (conga, bongos),
Eileen Gilbert (soprano vocals on #10 only).
Recorded in New York City, November 7, 1957.
#15 to #18 from the album The Jazz Modes (Atlantic LP1306):
#15, #16, #18:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Sahib Shihab (baritone sax), Gildo Mahones (piano),
Martin Rivera (bass), Jimmy Wormworth (drums).
Recorded in New York City, 1959.
#17:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Martin Rivera (bass),
Ron Jefferson (drums), Chino Pozo (congas, bongos),
Eileen Gilbert (soprano vocals).
Recorded in New York City, October 28, 1959.
*CD 3*
#1 to #4 from the album The Jazz Modes (Atlantic LP1306):
#1, #3, #4:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Gildo Mahones (piano), Martin Rivera (bass),
Ron Jefferson (drums), Chino Pozo (congas, bongos),
Eileen Gilbert (soprano vocals).
Recorded in New York City, October 28, 1959.
#2:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn),
Sahib Shihab (baritone sax), Gildo Mahones (piano),
Martin Rivera (bass), Jimmy Wormworth (drums).
Recorded in New York City, 1959.
#5 to #10: from the album Oscar Rides Again (Bethlehem 10” LP BCP1003),
[reissued on Bass (Bethlehem 12” LP BCP-6]:
Charlie Rouse (tenor sax), Julius Watkins (French horn), Duke Jordan (piano),
Oscar Pettiford (bass, cello on #6, #9,#10), Ron Jefferson (drums).
Recorded in New York City, September 1954.
#11 to #14: from the album Julius Watkins Sextet,
[a.k.a New Faces, New Sounds (Blue Note BLP5053)]:
Julius Watkins (French horn), Frank Foster (tenor sax),
George Butcher (piano), Perry Lopez (guitar),
Oscar Pettiford (bass), Kenny Clarke (drums).
Recorded at Van Gelder Studio, Hackensack, New Jersey, August 8, 1954.
#15 to #19: from the album Julius Watkins Sextet, Volume Two (Blue Note BLP5064):
Julius Watkins (French horn), Hank Mobley (tenor sax),
Duke Jordan (piano), Perry Lopez (guitar),
Oscar Pettiford (bass), Art Blakey (drums).
Recorded at Van Gelder Studio, Hackensack, New Jersey, March 20, 1955.